Balancing human and digital: Are banks losing touch with customers?

in partnership with


Logo of Avanade

Leading provider of digital, cloud and advisory services, industry solutions and design-led experiences via Microsoft.

View more
Digital Reinvention
26/06/2023 Study

The pressure on banks to be more responsive to customers is intensifying. Some banks have used this as an opportunity to go deeper into digital, increase automation in the business and have fewer people on the frontline. Branch numbers decline, self-service rises and digital engagement becomes the norm. But you sometimes need the skills of a detective to find a telephone number on a web site to speak to a human being about the advice you need.

For other banks, there is a deep recognition that people are key to creating customer trust but the cost of doing so is just too great. So, banks adopt a middle road, giving just enough support to those at the cutting-edge of customer engagement and hope that with minimum investment in technology and training, their people will somehow be able to handle the internal complexity placed before them every day – and still develop great customer relationships. Amazingly, sometimes they do.

Meanwhile, other customers get lost in call center options, turn up for branch interviews (booked online) where no one is available to see them, are offered products they’ve already bought from a competitor, cannot find anyone to speak to about the low savings rates they’re on (because they aren’t rich enough to get through to an advisor) or get the help they need as they spiral into debt (while the bank automatically charges overdraft fees).

Is there a way out of this?

Can banks intelligently blend human and digital to create personalised interactions, moments that matter, conversations with context? Are customers simply lost in a self-service, digital labyrinth that makes money for the bank but feels like an impersonal institution, devoid of emotion – great for those smart enough to navigate the system, but a nightmare for those who cannot? Is the best option always too expensive? In this high wire act of balancing human and digital interaction, what happens to the customer if the bank slips up?

The recent rise of large language models, such as ChatGPT, has highlighted not only how sophisticated chatbots have become due to Generative AI, but also the way in which such services can augment and tailor the customer journey at various points along the human-digital spectrum. The GPT models clearly have significant potential to become part of a data-driven, customer conversation that can be balanced with high touch, human engagement. The quality, speed and depth of ChatGPT’s responses have surprised many people and have got industry commentators wondering what this means for the future of customer engagement and the role and nature of search engines. But there are limits. Such models rely on copyrighted data to train them (an emerging legal issue), there is often bias, they lack a transparent audit trail and they sometimes produce strange answers. Clearly, they are not a silver bullet, but part of a spectrum of customer engagement tools to build customer trust.

Download study

Interviews made for this report

Digital Reinvention
02/08/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Bulgarian-American Credit Bank

Ivan Ivanov, Director of Retail Banking at Bulgarian-American Credit Bank, shares insights about his role and the challenges faced by...

Digital Reinvention
12/07/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: BPER Banca

Maurice Lisi, Head of Direct Channels BPER Banca, discusses the importance of striking a balance between digital innovation and human...

Digital Reinvention
18/08/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Desjardins

Dominic Larivée, the VP of Marketing Planning and Execution at Desjardins, discusses the dynamic landscape of digital banking and the...

Digital Reinvention
09/08/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Discovery Bank

Akash Dowra, Head of Client Insight at Discovery Bank in South Africa, provides valuable insights into the dynamic landscape of...

Digital Reinvention
25/08/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Eurobank Bulgaria (Postbank)

In this insightful interview with Nikolay Lazarov, Head of Sales Division for Retail Customers at Eurobank Bulgaria (Postbank), conducted for...

Digital Reinvention
19/07/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Mauritius Commercial Bank

Vincent Chatard, Chief Operating Officer of the Mauritius Commercial Bank, shares insights on the challenges confronting the bank's retail banking...

Digital Reinvention
26/07/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Macquarie Group

In this insightful interview, Aviram Vijh, Chief Design Officer of the Macquarie Group, shares his perspectives on the efforts of...

Digital Reinvention
28/06/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: TNEX

David Jiménez Maireles, the Chief Experience Officer of TNEX, shares his expertise on delivering exceptional customer experiences in the digital...

Digital Reinvention
05/07/2023 Interview

Balancing human and digital: Wealth One Bank of Canada

Barry Ferguson, the Chief Operating Officer of Wealth One Bank of Canada, shares his perspectives on various aspects of the...

Related news & insights

20/05/2024 News

Clearcover and Ada collaborate on customer-facing AI solution

This collaboration aims to revolutionize Clearcover's customer service experience by integrating Ada's 'AI Agent' into its platforms.

Digital Reinvention
15/05/2024 Article

Financial innovation spotlight: May 2024 edition

We have selected five new innovative projects that we found particularly interesting. A world tour that takes in France with...

Digital Reinvention
14/05/2024 News

Nirio launches Premio with FDJ: Simplifying everyday banking

Since January 2023, Nirio's payment solution has allowed individuals to pay for daily expenses in nearly 10,000 partner stores approved...

Digital Reinvention
13/05/2024 News

Nu Mexico surpasses 7 million customers, driven by rapid expansion and innovation

This rapid growth includes the addition of 2 million new customers within the last three months, fueled by continuous innovation...

Digital Reinvention
13/05/2024 Article

Banking Innovation of the Month: Santander Spain’s SME/wholesale user experience

Celebrating groundbreaking initiatives in the banking industry, we open this year’s monthly Qorus-Infosys Finacle Banking Innovation Awards with a spotlight...

Digital Reinvention
12/05/2024 News

Nubank launches Nubank+ and partners with Max in Brazil

Nubank, one of the world's largest digital financial services platforms, has announced the launch of Nubank+, an evolution of the...

SME Banking
11/05/2024 News

Chase announces new digital products to help small businesses grow

In the U.S., Chase has unveiled a series of new digital products aimed at helping small business owners tackle their...

08/05/2024 Study

The future of healthcare: Transforming the pathway to wellness

In the swiftly evolving domain of healthcare, advancements in technology and innovation are fundamentally altering the landscape of wellness. From...