Transforming banks into drivers of a positive future

By exploring the various strategies and initiatives that banks are implementing to enhance their social impact, we can gain insight into how these efforts are reshaping the financial industry. Through case studies and data-driven insights, the significant progress being made and the potential for continued positive transformation within the banking sector become evident. These developments help us better understand the multifaceted role banks play in fostering a more inclusive and equitable society.

02/07/2024 Study

In an era marked by heightened awareness of social and environmental issues, banks are increasingly adopting roles that extend beyond traditional financial services. Historically, the primary mission of banks centered on profitability, with a focus on wealth creation and financial growth. However, the contemporary banking landscape is experiencing a paradigm shift. Financial institutions are now striving to contribute positively to society, reflecting a broader commitment to ethical practices and sustainable development.

This growing trend is not just a response to regulatory changes or public pressure; it is a strategic realignment that addresses evolving consumer expectations and global challenges. Banks are targeting specific areas such as gender and minority inclusion, financial inclusion, poverty alleviation, and support for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). These efforts are designed to foster economic stability, promote social equity, and drive inclusive growth. 

By exploring the various strategies and initiatives that banks are implementing to enhance their social impact, we can gain insight into how these efforts are reshaping the financial industry. Through case studies and data-driven insights, the significant progress being made and the potential for continued positive transformation within the banking sector become evident. These developments help us better understand the multifaceted role banks play in fostering a more inclusive and equitable society.

The evolution of banking missions

Banking has undergone a remarkable transformation over the centuries. Traditionally, the mission of banks revolved around profitability and innovation. From the early days of the Medici family in Renaissance Italy, who established a network of banking practices that laid the foundation for modern finance, to the rise of powerful investment banks in the 20th century, the focus was on wealth creation and financial growth. Innovation took the form of new financial products and services designed to maximize returns and shareholder value, often prioritizing short-term gains.

However, banking missions are shifting dramatically in the 21st century. In recent years, there has been a significant move towards integrating ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) principles into the core strategies of financial institutions. While environmental concerns and governance issues are crucial, the ‘S’ or social aspect has gained particular prominence. Banks are increasingly acknowledging their role in addressing social challenges, from financial inclusion and community development to fair lending practices and equitable economic opportunities.

This shift is not merely a response to regulatory pressures or social demands, but also a strategic move to align with the values of a more socially conscious clientele. In the UK, for example, a Deloitte survey found that 71% of banking customers are more likely to choose a bank with a positive social and environmental impact – a sentiment that is widely echoed across contemporary global markets.

As part of this evolution, banks are rebranding themselves to emphasize their beneficial contributions to society. Marketing campaigns now highlight stories of community support, sustainable investments, and initiatives aimed at improving social equity. By leveraging these narratives, banks aim to build trust and loyalty among consumers, who increasingly demand that their financial choices align with their values.

This reimagining of banking missions marks a significant transition from the traditional profit-centric approach, positioning banks as pivotal players in fostering a more inclusive and equitable society. As banks continue to strengthen, their success will probably be measured not just by their financial performance but by their contributions to the broader social good.

Gender and minority inclusion

The financial sector has long grappled with issues of gender and minority exclusion. Historically, banking has been a male-dominated industry, with women and minorities facing significant barriers to entry and advancement. A 2020 Deloitte report noted that women held only 19% of C-suite positions in global financial services. Meanwhile, the proportion of racial and ethnic minorities in senior roles is even lower in many countries like the US. This underrepresentation is not just a matter of fairness but also affects the sector's innovation, risk management, and overall performance. Diverse teams bring varied perspectives, which can enhance decision-making and drive better business outcomes.

Recognizing these challenges, many financial institutions have launched initiatives and programs aimed at promoting gender and minority inclusion. These efforts are multifaceted, targeting recruitment, retention, and advancement. Leadership development programs are a key strategy. For instance, Crédit Mutuel Arkéa's Gender mission initiative resulted in a substantial increase in female managers and executives, with their representation growing from 18% in 2015 to 33% in 2022. Among the banks aiming for complete gender parity, Banque Palatine has made remarkable strides, attaining an equality index of 95%, with some 47% of executive positions held by women. 

Such inclusion initiatives extend beyond board rooms to banks’ clientele and society at large, with forward-thinking institutions launching programs to empower women and minorities with improved access to financial products and education. Many banks are also proactively supporting entrepreneurship in these historically disadvantaged groups, to level the playing field and drive economic growth while fostering inclusivity and social equity.

Citigroup's Action for Racial Equity, for example, invested $1 billion in strategic initiatives to help close the racial wealth gap and increase economic mobility in the United States. Similarly, Wells Fargo's Banking Inclusion Initiative seeks to ensure access to affordable mainstream accounts and low-cost banking services, along with financial education, for unbanked communities, specifically targeting Black and African American, Hispanic, and Native American families.

Among the financial institutions working to promote gender equality and support female entrepreneurship in society at large, Ecuador’s Banco Pichincha stands out for its SER Impulso Mujer program, which provides funding and resources to women entrepreneurs. Singapore’s OCBC Bank and Kenya’s KCB Bank have launched similar programs, helping to close the gender gap in business ownership and unlock the full potential of female-led enterprises. Banca Widiba, meanwhile, has positioned itself as a staunch champion of gender equality, undertaking extensive research into stereotypes that perpetuate the exclusion of women from the financial sphere.  

Besides the broader societal benefits, inclusivity initiatives also have a clear impact on performance and business outcomes within the organizations that implement them. According to Deloitte, embracing diversity enhances creativity and innovation by 20%, enables better decisions 87% of the time, and speeds up decision-making by a factor of two. Likewise, a 2017 survey conducted by the BCG found that financial institutions that actively promote diversity see a 19% higher revenue from innovation compared to their less diverse counterparts. This correlation between diversity and financial performance illustrates that inclusion is not just a moral imperative but a business one as well.

Financial inclusion

Financial inclusion, defined as the process of ensuring access to appropriate, affordable, and timely financial products and services for all individuals, especially underserved and unbanked populations, is fundamental to promoting economic stability and growth. It empowers individuals and businesses by providing them with the tools needed to manage income, save, invest in opportunities, and protect against economic vulnerabilities. In essence, financial inclusion fosters economic resilience and growth, reduces poverty, and enhances shared prosperity.

Banks around the world are employing various strategies to advance financial inclusion. Besides the minority inclusion, microcredit and financial education initiatives covered in this report, technology has clearly emerged as a key driver in the democratization of access to financial services. In the space of just a few years, mobile banking and digital platforms have allowed financial institutions to expand their reach to geographically or demographically underserved populations: according to a World Bank report, the percentage of adults worldwide with an account at a bank or mobile money provider increased from 51% in 2011 to 69% in 2017. 

The digital banking revolution is particularly relevant in emerging economies, where until recently many people had little or no access to formal financial services. Pioneering banks like UNO in the Phillippines and BRAC Bank in Bangladesh are now leveraging technology to extend their services to the unbanked and underbanked, fostering inclusion and economic empowerment. 

Among the technological innovations powering financial inclusion, mobile money systems have had a remarkable impact in regions where traditional banking infrastructure is lacking. These cellphone-based services, which can be used with or without a bank account, not only increase accessibility but also significantly reduce transaction costs, making financial services more affordable for low-income individuals.

Case studies from Africa, where large proportions of the population remain unbanked but cellphone ownership has become the norm, showcase the transformative power of mobile money. In Kenya, for example the adoption of mobile money accounts has lifted an estimated 194,000 households out of extreme poverty. Similarly, Fonbnk, which enables users to convert mobile airtime into cryptocurrencies, attracted nearly 50,000 users across African economies in its first two years of operation, highlighting the effectiveness of targeted micro-banking programs. 

Partnerships between governments and financial institutions have also proven highly effective in advancing financial inclusion. In Cambodia, for example, the government teamed up with Wing Bank to enable the rapid and transparent distribution of funds to those in need through Wing Cash Xpress, offering a lifeline for millions during the Covid-19 pandemic. And in India, the Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yojana program created 175 million bank accounts in just one year for those previously without banking access, unlocking access to the digital economy for a huge swathe of the population. 

In this digital era, low-tech solutions still have their place in driving financial inclusion in remote areas. Numerous banks have rolled out ‘banks on wheels’ to serve clients who lack access to physical branches, and some, like Banco Bradesco and Westpac, even use boats to provide services to islanders and remote riverine communities. Agent banking is another strategy that has proven highly effective in reaching underserved areas, as exemplified by Land Bank of the Philippines and Prime Bank in Bangladesh, both of which use a network of agents to bridge the financial inclusion gap in rural and semi-urban locales.

Fighting poverty

Banks have a crucial role to play in the fight against poverty. By leveraging their financial resources and expertise, banks can implement a range of strategies to help lift individuals and communities out of poverty. These strategies include providing microloans, investing in local communities, and supporting social banking initiatives.

One of the most impactful ways banks contribute to poverty alleviation is through microcredit. Microloans provide small amounts of capital to individuals or small businesses that lack access to traditional banking services. These loans are particularly effective in developing countries, where they can help entrepreneurs start or expand businesses, thus creating jobs and stimulating economic growth. Grameen Bank, widely regarded as a pioneer in the microfinance sector, has helped millions of people lift themselves out of poverty through its microcredit programs. Studies have shown that access to microloans not only increases household income but also improves access to education and healthcare, leading to broader socio-economic benefits.

Social banking initiatives are another powerful tool in the fight against poverty. These programs focus on providing financial services to underserved populations, including low-income families and marginalized communities. By offering affordable banking options, financial literacy programs, and tailored financial products, social banks help to break down the barriers that prevent individuals from accessing mainstream financial services.

Community investments are also essential for poverty reduction. By investing in local infrastructure, housing, and small businesses, banks can stimulate economic activity and job creation. These investments often take the form of community development funds, which are designed to address specific local needs. 

Agriculture is one such area where targeted initiatives have proven highly effective in alleviating poverty. In China, for example, Ping An's Poverty Alleviation Project has aided agricultural development in over 30 regions across 12 provinces, benefiting over 26,000 impoverished households, and their  Agricultural Products Intelligent Traceability Platform System has further enabled rural producers to increase revenue and reduce costs. 

The outcomes of these efforts are measurable and significant. Metrics such as job creation, increased access to financial services, and improved economic stability highlight the positive impact banks can have on poverty levels. For example, a report by the National Alliance of Community Economic Development Association found that community-targeted investments in disadvantaged areas of the US yield a financial return of up to US$6.77 for every US$1 invested. Additionally, microloan programs have consistently shown high repayment rates, indicating both the financial viability and the positive impact of these initiatives on poverty reduction.

Supporting SMEs

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are often hailed as the backbone of any economy, driving innovation, employment, and economic resilience. Representing approximately 90% of businesses and more than 50% of employment worldwide, SMEs are pivotal in fostering economic diversity and growth. They play a critical role in generating jobs, stimulating local economies, and contributing to GDP. However, SMEs face numerous challenges, including limited access to finance, inadequate business networks, and insufficient managerial expertise. These obstacles can stymie their potential and hinder overall economic progress.

To address these challenges, banks have developed a variety of initiatives tailored to support SME growth. One such approach involves offering specialized financial products and services. Banks provide loans, credit lines, and other financing options designed to meet the unique needs of SMEs, ensuring they have the necessary capital to invest in growth opportunities. For instance, BNP Paribas Bank Polska offers a comprehensive banking service tailored for innovative companies and startups, providing dedicated relationship managers, digital processes, specialized credit policies, wealth management support, and cross-border connections to facilitate stable growth and international expansion. 

In addition to these financial products, banks also offer advisory services that deliver vital business advice and support. Programs that provide strategic guidance, market insights, and mentorship can be transformative for SMEs. Georgia’s TBC Bank showcases this approach, offering comprehensive support to SMEs through a variety of tailored financial products, innovative digital services, and extensive non-financial resources such as mentorship, educational programs, and business tools. These services help SMEs enhance their business acumen, develop robust business plans, and navigate complex regulatory environments.

Here, again, microcredit programs provide a lifeline for many small businesses and entrepreneurs who lack access to traditional banking services. CaixaBank’s MicroBank, for example, has played a remarkable role in stimulating economic growth and helping to create tens of thousands of jobs in Spain, through microloans that enable recipients to start or expand their businesses. The impact of such initiatives is profound, with countless success stories of small enterprises that have flourished due to the support provided by microfinance institutions.

Case studies from leading banks illustrate the effectiveness of these initiatives. BNP Paribas's commitment to SME support is evident in its comprehensive SME Pact initiative, having financed €60 million over the course of five years in order to encourage innovation and entrepreneurship across France. This program provides not only financial support but also security enhancements to combat fraud, and includes commitments to support social entrepreneurs and international development. Similarly, Banco Bradesco's initiatives have led to significant successes, with many participating SMEs reporting increased revenues and business growth.

Improving customer financial health

Improving customers’ financial health has emerged as a critical priority for banks in recent years. It entails assisting individuals in managing their finances effectively, thereby fostering economic stability and resilience at both the individual and societal levels.

Financial health encompasses various aspects, including budgeting, saving, investing, and managing debt. It signifies individuals' ability to meet their financial obligations, plan for the future, and navigate unexpected financial shocks. Moreover, it extends beyond mere financial literacy to encompass access to affordable financial services and products that meet individuals' needs.

Enhancing financial health is crucial for individuals as it empowers them to achieve their financial goals and aspirations. Moreover, it reduces stress and anxiety associated with financial insecurity, thereby improving overall well-being. From a societal perspective, improved financial health contributes to economic stability, reduces reliance on social safety nets, and fosters a more financially inclusive society.

Banks play a pivotal role in improving customer financial health through various strategies:

1- Financial literacy programs: Many banks offer educational initiatives aimed at enhancing customers' financial literacy. These programs provide valuable knowledge and skills, such as budgeting, saving, and investing, empowering individuals to make informed financial decisions.

2- Tools and resources: Digital tools and resources have become integral components of banks' efforts to improve customer financial health. These include budgeting apps, retirement calculators, and financial planning software, enabling customers to track their finances, set goals, and make strategic financial decisions.

In Morocco, for instance, Attijariwafa Bank has launched the Dar Al Moukhawil program, offering workshops, online resources, and personalized consultations, to promote financial education nationwide. With 21 dedicated centers and a platform boasting nearly 2.5 million registered users, the initiative promises to have a far-reaching impact. Similarly, Banco Bradesco’s Ágora Academy is committed to democratizing access to financial education in Brazil, offering free courses alongside training and professional certification programs. 

In France, meanwhile, La Banque Postale is supporting initiatives to counter over-indebtedness, and, through its crowdfunding platform KissKissBankBank, connects local authorities with community projects under a ‘mentorship’ program to enhance fundraising efforts. Financial literacy initiatives for elderly individuals, who are often particularly vulnerable to financial scams and frauds, are another key outreach area, as exemplified by Itaú Unibanco’s WhatsApp-based financial education program in Brazil. 

Many financial institutions have launched digital finance management tools in recent years, empowering customers to take charge of their own financial health. Santander UK’s Budget Calculator and Financial Health Check, for example, have enabled over two million customers to receive support and guidance in managing their finances amid rising living costs. Wells Fargo’s LifeSync financial planning tool provides customers with comprehensive support in reaching their financial goals, responding to the growing demand for digital financial advice, especially among Gen Z. And Raiffeisen Bank International is starting its financial education efforts at an even earlier age, targeting young teenagers with its engaging Minecraft financial literacy game My Finance Quests

Conclusion: The future of positive banking

As we look ahead, the future of banking appears increasingly intertwined with the pursuit of positive impact. Emerging trends suggest a continued emphasis on sustainability, social responsibility, and ethical governance within the financial sector. One significant prediction is the mainstream adoption of impact investing, where banks allocate capital to projects and businesses that generate measurable social and environmental benefits alongside financial returns. This aligns with the growing demand from consumers and investors for transparent and ethical banking practices.

However, as banks navigate this transition towards a more socially conscious model, they may encounter several challenges. One such hurdle is the need to balance profitability with purpose. While there is a clear business case for positive banking, achieving sustainable financial returns while simultaneously maximizing social impact requires innovative approaches and long-term commitment. Additionally, regulatory complexities and market uncertainties could pose obstacles to the widespread adoption of positive banking practices.

To address these challenges, banks must embrace technology and data analytics to better measure and report their social and environmental impact. Collaborations with government agencies, NGOs, and other stakeholders can also provide valuable insights and resources to support positive banking initiatives. Moreover, fostering a culture of transparency and accountability within the organization is crucial for building trust and credibility with customers and investors.

Looking forward, the vision for the future of positive banking involves a holistic approach that goes beyond financial transactions to foster meaningful relationships and create shared value for all stakeholders. This entails reimagining banking as a catalyst for positive change, where every decision and action is guided by a commitment to sustainability, social equity, and ethical integrity. By embracing this visionary approach, banks can not only drive positive outcomes for society but also secure their relevance and resilience in an ever-evolving financial landscape.


Read more Qorus Digest reports

ESG community

With Qorus memberships, you gain access to exclusive innovation best practices and tailored matchmaking opportunities with executives who share your challenges.

Related Content